These two jewels certainly have some things in common, such as eye-catching beauty and a rich green hue. But in reality, they’re still quite different from each other. While emerald belongs to the league of premier jewels, tsavorite is seen merely as a look alike. But there’s more to this gem than meets the eye.
Check this comparative analysis to find out.
Emerald vs. Tsavorite: What’s the Difference?
When we say the words ‘green gemstone’, what’s the first thing that comes to mind? We bet it’s either an emerald or tsavorite.
Interestingly, these stones are often mistaken for each other due to their similar hues.
But is there really any difference between the two?
Let’s find out…
1. Symbolism
The emerald is believed to symbolize rebirth, good fortune, youth, peace, balance, and growth. Tsavorite, on the other hand, is believed to represent strength, vitality, and positivity.
2. Durability
With a score of 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, the emerald happens to be a tad stronger among the two. Tsavorite isn’t far behind and has a rating of 7 to 7.5 on the Mohs scale.
Note: While both these gemstones are considerably durable, they must be treated with extra care and precaution if one intends to wear either of them on a daily basis.
3. Treatment
Emeralds often undergo treatments to improve their colour and reduce the appearance of flaws/inclusions. They may also be subjected to oiling procedures to fill internal fractures, if any. On the contrary, the colour of a tsavorite is completely natural and it does not require any type of enhancements, besides the regular polishing.
4. Price Point
Heirloom-quality emeralds, especially those with minimal flaws, can be quite expensive. It is also categorized as a precious gem and is the official birthstone of May, which further makes it extremely valuable, therefore equally costly. Tsavorites, on the other hand, are comparatively more affordable.
5. Colour
The finest and most sought-after emeralds often display a vibrant green colour, with blue as a secondary hue. High-quality tsavorites display a vivid green colour, and undertones of yellow are not preferred.
6. Rarity
Emeralds are relatively easy to find as their mines are located all across the globe. Tsavorites, however, are only found in Africa. This fact makes it rarer than many gemstones, including the emerald.
7. Clarity
Even the best quality emeralds tend to have some inclusions, which often look like pieces of grass. These are known as ‘jardin’ – French for ‘garden’. Unless it’s a deep internal fracture or dark colour zoning that’s visible on the surface, the flaws in an emerald are often considered as an intrinsic characteristic of the gem. Tsavorites are type 2 gemstones, so it’s normal for them also to have inclusions. Eye-visible flaws, however, can bring down the value of this jewel.
8. Popularity
Emeralds are a part of the ‘big 3’ of coloured and precious gemstones. They have also been revered across different civilizations of the world since the beginning of time, which is why they are more famous. The tsavorite is a relatively new stone, but its rarity and beauty have gradually led to its popularity.
Good to Know:
Although tsavorite resembles the emerald, in reality it is an expensive type of garnet (grossular). This gem cannot be found anywhere else on earth except for east Africa; Kenya’s Taita and the Arusha region in Tanzania being the primary sources. This fact makes tsavorite much rarer than emeralds. It also has a good refractive index, which means its brilliance will be considerably high. Tsavorite, unlike an emerald, does not have gemstone cleavage; this property results in breakage when hit hard. Overall, it certainly offers good value for money.
Verdict:
Emerald is more popular between the two gems, and for good reason. Its name and beauty is instantly recognised around the world. Along with sapphire and ruby, emerald is also one of the ‘big three’ of coloured gems; a title that highlights the value and demand for these precious jewels. So it is not surprising that a good-quality emerald can be very expensive.
Shop Emerald Jewellery:
Tsavorite, on the other hand, does not have much demand simply because many people are still not aware of its existence. However, it is celebrated by collectors and connoisseurs of the jewellery world. So if you’re looking for a great alternative to emerald that is beautiful, considerably durable and doesn’t burn a hole in your pocket, then tsavorite is sure to be a wonderful purchase.
Both the emerald and tsavorite are spectacular stones in their own right. While one is ancient and famous, the other can be considered a more contemporary gem that’s also extremely rare. But regardless of which one you choose, we’re sure you’ll end up with an absolute stunner.
